egg soldiers - 'Ask the food experts'
Coffee Chain Food Strategy:
Winning Moves for 2026 and Beyond
Winning Moves for 2026 and Beyond
Egg Soldiers outlines three key focus areas when future-proofing coffee shop food strategy for 2026
Coffee Chain Food Strategy
Rethinking & Refreshing
Rethinking & Refreshing
Coffee shops have never been busier. And as the sector continues to grow, so too do customer expectations. And in 2026, people won't just come for caffeine, they will come for convenience, comfort and a sense of care.
Food is no longer an optional extra for operators; it’s the difference between a customer who grabs a latte and leaves, and one who stays, spends more, and comes back.
Yet many coffee businesses still struggle to make food work. Some overcomplicate their range, chasing every trend. Others play it too safe, missing the chance to build excitement.
The winners in this market are those with a clear food identity - simple, recognisable and consistently executed - that elevates the coffee moment rather than distracting from it.
So how do you build a food strategy that hits the mark? Based on years of consultancy experience in this space, our award-winning team has identified three essential pillars every coffee shop or chain must master.
Food is no longer an optional extra for operators; it’s the difference between a customer who grabs a latte and leaves, and one who stays, spends more, and comes back.
Yet many coffee businesses still struggle to make food work. Some overcomplicate their range, chasing every trend. Others play it too safe, missing the chance to build excitement.
The winners in this market are those with a clear food identity - simple, recognisable and consistently executed - that elevates the coffee moment rather than distracting from it.
So how do you build a food strategy that hits the mark? Based on years of consultancy experience in this space, our award-winning team has identified three essential pillars every coffee shop or chain must master.
1
Beverage-Led Thinking
Coffee is the hero, and food its natural partner.
The most resilient strategies begin with this truth. Every item on the menu should answer one simple question: what drink does this go with, and when?
Morning Missions: A freshly-made cappuccino pairs perfectly with a warm, portable breakfast option. Think hot baps, croissants, or porridge pots - simple formats that are fast, filling and familiar.
Lunchtime Needs: Iced coffees and soft drinks often accompany sandwiches, toasties or wraps. The priority here is clarity and speed of choice - customers shouldn’t have to hunt through clutter to find something satisfying.
Afternoon Pick-Me-Ups: The post-lunch lull is prime time for indulgence. Cakes, cookies, and traybakes work hardest when they feel fresh and celebratory, not mass-produced.
The most resilient strategies begin with this truth. Every item on the menu should answer one simple question: what drink does this go with, and when?
Morning Missions: A freshly-made cappuccino pairs perfectly with a warm, portable breakfast option. Think hot baps, croissants, or porridge pots - simple formats that are fast, filling and familiar.
Lunchtime Needs: Iced coffees and soft drinks often accompany sandwiches, toasties or wraps. The priority here is clarity and speed of choice - customers shouldn’t have to hunt through clutter to find something satisfying.
Afternoon Pick-Me-Ups: The post-lunch lull is prime time for indulgence. Cakes, cookies, and traybakes work hardest when they feel fresh and celebratory, not mass-produced.
2
Familiar Done Brilliantly
There’s a temptation in food development to reinvent the wheel.
But in coffee shops, customers crave trust. They want the formats they know - sandwiches, toasties, muffins, cookies - but they want them done well, every time.
Why familiarity wins:
It reduces decision friction: Guests can scan a counter and instantly understand what’s on offer.
It scales easily: Operators can execute consistently across hundreds of sites without confusion.
It anchors brand confidence: A perfectly toasted cheese sandwich or indulgent chocolate cake can do more for reputation than a dozen experimental dishes.
The opportunity isn’t in inventing new formats, but in owning the classics. A chain can become famous for its breakfast bap, its millionaire’s shortbread, or its croissant – provided the quality is consistent, the presentation sharp and the experience reliable.
But in coffee shops, customers crave trust. They want the formats they know - sandwiches, toasties, muffins, cookies - but they want them done well, every time.
Why familiarity wins:
It reduces decision friction: Guests can scan a counter and instantly understand what’s on offer.
It scales easily: Operators can execute consistently across hundreds of sites without confusion.
It anchors brand confidence: A perfectly toasted cheese sandwich or indulgent chocolate cake can do more for reputation than a dozen experimental dishes.
The opportunity isn’t in inventing new formats, but in owning the classics. A chain can become famous for its breakfast bap, its millionaire’s shortbread, or its croissant – provided the quality is consistent, the presentation sharp and the experience reliable.
Looking to revamp your coffee shop menu?
Reach out to our expert team to discuss your support needs!
Reach out to our expert team to discuss your support needs!
Get in touch
Leave us a message and we'll get back to you
3
Playful Elevation
Once the foundations are in place, it’s time to add excitement.
Customers want a reason to come back beyond routine - and that’s where playful elevation comes in.
This is about taking familiar formats and giving them a twist. A limited-edition seasonal doughnut. A toastie with a bold, unexpected flavour. A cake designed to be as photogenic as it is delicious.
These products don’t have to appeal to everyone - their job is to create 'talkability' and shine a halo over the whole range.
The rules of playful elevation:
Keep it simple: No complex prep, no lengthy training.
Make it shareable: Insta-worthy, but also operationally deliverable.
Use it sparingly: No more than a handful of items at any one time.
Customers want a reason to come back beyond routine - and that’s where playful elevation comes in.
This is about taking familiar formats and giving them a twist. A limited-edition seasonal doughnut. A toastie with a bold, unexpected flavour. A cake designed to be as photogenic as it is delicious.
These products don’t have to appeal to everyone - their job is to create 'talkability' and shine a halo over the whole range.
The rules of playful elevation:
Keep it simple: No complex prep, no lengthy training.
Make it shareable: Insta-worthy, but also operationally deliverable.
Use it sparingly: No more than a handful of items at any one time.
Not sure what support you need?
4
Execution is Everything
A strategy is only as strong as its delivery. In the coffee shop environment, counter execution and customer journey are critical.
Simplicity sells: Counters overloaded with packaging, colours, or signage confuse guests. Strip it back. Let the food do the talking.
Segment clearly: Customers should instantly see where to go for breakfast, lunch, or sweet treats. When ranges are jumbled together, missions get lost.
Freshness cues matter: Bakery racks, simple craft papers, and glass-fronted cases send signals of quality without a word of marketing.
Impulse moments: Position food where it naturally supports the beverage journey - from pastries at entry to cookies at the till.
Simplicity sells: Counters overloaded with packaging, colours, or signage confuse guests. Strip it back. Let the food do the talking.
Segment clearly: Customers should instantly see where to go for breakfast, lunch, or sweet treats. When ranges are jumbled together, missions get lost.
Freshness cues matter: Bakery racks, simple craft papers, and glass-fronted cases send signals of quality without a word of marketing.
Impulse moments: Position food where it naturally supports the beverage journey - from pastries at entry to cookies at the till.
The Bottom Line.
- Beverage-led thinkingDesign food to complement coffee moments - portable breakfasts, indulgent treats, or lunch pairings - creating natural upsell opportunities and maximising value from every customer visit.
- Familiar done brilliantlyOwn the classics - toasties, cakes, pastries - executed flawlessly every time. Consistency drives repeat purchase, customer confidence, and scalable success across coffee shop formats and locations.
- Playful elevationSeasonal specials and creative twists on favourites spark curiosity, generate talkability, and keep menus dynamic, refreshing the customer experience without operational complexity.
Coffee Chain Food Strategy
Supporting your Journey
Supporting your Journey
With decades of shaping food strategies for leading hospitality brands, Egg Soldiers knows what it takes to build an offer that truly delivers.
From big-picture positioning to operational detail, we partner with coffee shops and chains to unlock more from their food: more sales, more clarity, more customer impact.
But how do we transform strategy into reality? How do we turn an underperforming range into something sharper, leaner, and commercially stronger?
To give you a flavour, we’ve created a series of FREE showcases that demonstrate our approach – based on a hypothetical client and sample brief.
From big-picture positioning to operational detail, we partner with coffee shops and chains to unlock more from their food: more sales, more clarity, more customer impact.
But how do we transform strategy into reality? How do we turn an underperforming range into something sharper, leaner, and commercially stronger?
To give you a flavour, we’ve created a series of FREE showcases that demonstrate our approach – based on a hypothetical client and sample brief.
Contact us for more information on our services
Discover our menu development process!
Discover our new concept creation process!
Discover our strategic process!
Some of our Success Stories!
Business we've supported with fresh eyes expertise!